Social Justice: Lessons from a Discussion

Authors

  • Alvaro Perpere Viñuales Pontificia Universidad Católica Argentina

Keywords:

SOCIAL JUSTICE, JACQUES MARITAIN, CATHOLIC ECONOMISTS, CHRISTIAN HUMANISM, SOCIAL DOCTRINE OF THE CHURCH

Abstract

In 1947 a group of American Catholic intellectuals gathered in Uruguay signed the Declaration of Montevideo. In it, the signatories pledged to influence on their countries politics on the basis of the Social Doctrine of the Church. In subsequent years, many of them held important government positions in both the Executive branch and in the Legislative branch. In the Argentine case, however, the matter was not easy. On the return of the delegates, it began
a complex controversy around the present social economic principles in the Declaration, among them the problem of the meaning of the notion of social justice and its relation to the capitalist economy. This article seeks to examine the main positions that were generated in this debate, showing the efforts of each of these authors to specify the content of this idea and its relation to economic and social sciences. Particularly, the challenge they had to face was to address to what extent the Christian social thought was consistent with the capitalist economy that, after the Second World War, appeared as the only possible economic model against communism, or if it was necessary to think of a better alternative.

Downloads

Download data is not yet available.

References

Coll Benegas, C. (1947a) “Sobre el capital y el trabajo”, en Orden Cristiano, 140, agosto de 1947.

Coll Benegas, C. (1947b) “Una carta”, en Orden Cristiano, 135, junio de 1947.

Compagnon, O. (2003) Jacques Maritain et L’Amérique du Sud. Le modèle malgre, Presses Universitaires du Septentrion, Paris.

Duhau, A. (1947a) “Discurso en la ciudad de Montevideo”, en Orden Cristiano, VI, 135.

Duhau, A. (1947b) La Iglesia, la Justicia Social y la Riqueza, Editorial Orden Cristiano, Buenos Aires.

Durelli, A. (1945) “Un recuerdo al Dr. Rafael Pividal”, en Orden Cristiano, 94.

Franceshi, G. (1945) “Rafael Pividal”, en Criterio, 907.

Krapf, E. (1945) “In Memoriam Rafael Pividal”; en Orden Cristiano, 94.

Parera, R. G. (1986) Los Demócratas Cristianos Argentinos. Testimonio de una experiencia política, Buschi, Buenos Aires, T1.

Peña, H. (1947). “Carta”, en Orden Cristiano, 136.

Pérez Catán, M. (1947) “A propósito del Manifiesto Demócrata Cristiano de Montevideo”, Orden Cristiano.

Pérez Catán, M. (1948) “Hombre total”, en Criterio, 1076, 1 de noviembre de 1948.

Pérez Catán, M. (1952) “Defensa cultural contra el comunismo”, en Criterio, 1138.

Pividal, R. (1938) “Católicos fascistas y católicos personalistas”, en Sur, 35.

Pividal, R. (1944) “Nota sobre un francés dilecto”, en Orden Cristiano, 73.

Pividal, R. (1939) “Una Nueva Cristiandad”, Acción católica y acción política, tomo Maritain, Losada, Buenos Aires.

Puiggros, Oscar (1947) “Entrevista de Jaime Potenze a Oscar Puiggros” en Orden Cristiano, 148, diciembre de 1947.

Vila Echagüe, I. (1947) “Carta”, en Orden Cristiano, 136, junio de 1947

Vila Echagüe, I. (1952) “Notas sobre la planificación”, en Criterio, 1156, 24 de enero de 1952.

Vila Echagüe, I. (1960) Cuestiones disputadas en la Democracia Cristiana, Ed. del Atlántico, Buenos Aires.

Published

2019-11-13

How to Cite

Perpere Viñuales, A. (2019). Social Justice: Lessons from a Discussion. Cultura Económica, 29(81-82), 54–63. Retrieved from https://e-revistas.uca.edu.ar/index.php/CECON/article/view/2467